
Braun made his statements and the MLB made theirs and it looks like Braun will be able to start the season on Opening Day, but that doesn't come without controversy and as a Ryan Braun and Brewers fan I am torn and still have numerous questions hanging in the balance before I will feel right about cheering for him.
First and foremost: His defense in the appeal apparently didn't hinge only on this 44-48 hour period that the tester had his sample, so what did it focus on?
He hasn't addressed if the sample was tampered, which leaves no answer for why synthetic testosterone was found in his system. And if they do claim that it was tampered with is their any evidence at all?
It was released by
ESPN that Braun volunteered to take a DNA test for the MLB to see if that was even his urine and the MLB declined. Why would the MLB decline this? I guess it wouldn't prove much for Braun because he never claimed it wasn't his urine, but if the DNA test showed it wasn't the MLB would have virtually no integrity with their testing program.
My next thought is that Braun should VOLUNTARILY be tested during every round of testing (not sure how frequently that is) or at least once per month throughout the season. This would at least restore some credibility to him as being a loyal player moving forward. Does he have to do this? No, but he should. It would show his faith in the drug program and show that he is willing to go the extra mile to make sure his season's in the future are not tainted.
Either way, I'm left with a ton of questions. I truly want to believe that Braun never thought about touching roids, but just as I reserved my judgement on Braun when the initial report came out I'm going to put the celebrating on hold until everything about his appeal is more clear. And that's all a fan can really do. These facts may never come out and in the meantime I'll enjoy watching Braun play, but in the back of my mind will be a quandary, an extra thought to whether or not my favorite baseball player is truly clean.
My fan brain says, "Of course he's clean, he won his appeal, that's that... Brewers 2012!". My rational brain says, "Wait a minute, there's a lot of things that had to happen for this test to be false, just because he won his appeal and gets to play the whole season doesn't mean he didn't do it." But the facts aren't there...yet.